Lake Geneva Pie Co Menu (Updated September 2025)

Welcome to Lake Geneva Pie Co, a delightful gem nestled in the heart of Lake Geneva, Wisconsin. This charming café offers a menu rich in indulgent flavors and heartwarming hospitality. From the moment you step inside, you’re greeted by a cozy ambiance that invites you to savor every bite.

• Signature Pies: The star of the show is undoubtedly their award-winning pies. Customers rave about the Cherry Crumb and Blueberry Crumble pies, with many returning to try more flavors like the Raspberry and Lakeshore pies. Each slice is a testament to the bakery's commitment to using fresh, quality ingredients.
• Comforting Savories: Beyond pies, the menu also boasts delicious quiches, hearty soups, and soft peanut butter cookies that have become fan favorites. Each dish is made from scratch, ensuring a homemade touch that warms the heart.
• Family-Friendly Atmosphere: The café's adorable decor, complete with tic-tac-toe tables, makes it an inviting spot for families. The friendly staff is always ready to help, creating an experience that feels both personal and welcoming.

Whether you’re looking for a sweet treat or a comforting meal, Lake Geneva Pie Co delivers a memorable dining experience that keeps you coming back for more. Don’t miss the chance to indulge in their delicious offerings!